Policies

AURAS · PUBLICATION POLICIES

Editorial and Publication Policies

Architecture, Urban Research and Analytical Studies

Architecture, Urban Research and Analytical Studies (AURAS) is committed to maintaining academic integrity, editorial independence, transparency, and responsible scholarly publishing in architecture, urban studies, and related disciplines.

The following policies describe the journal's editorial principles, peer review procedures, and expectations regarding ethical research and publication. Additional operational policies will be published following their formal approval.

1. Editorial Independence

Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, originality, methodological quality, relevance to the journal's aims and scope, and compliance with ethical standards.

Editors exercise independent academic judgment and must avoid inappropriate influence from authors, reviewers, institutional affiliations, publishers, sponsors, or other interested parties.

2. Double-Blind Peer Review Policy

AURAS operates a double-blind peer review model. Under this model, the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another throughout the review process.

2.1 Initial Editorial Screening

Submitted manuscripts are initially assessed by the editorial team for:

  • Relevance to the aims and scope of the journal;
  • Originality, innovation, and scholarly contribution;
  • Clarity of research objectives and questions;
  • Methodological and academic quality;
  • Appropriateness of architectural, spatial, technical, or analytical methods;
  • Compliance with submission requirements and applicable ethical principles.

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's basic requirements may be declined before external peer review.

2.2 Reviewer Selection

Manuscripts considered suitable for external review are assigned to independent reviewers with relevant expertise in architecture, urban planning, building sciences, environmental design, or related disciplines.

Reviewers must disclose potential conflicts of interest and decline assignments where impartial evaluation may be compromised.

2.3 Confidentiality and Anonymity

Authors must prepare anonymized manuscript files and remove identifying information that could compromise double-blind review.

Reviewers must treat manuscripts, architectural drawings, design documents, technical data, supplementary materials, and editorial correspondence as confidential.

2.4 Review Criteria

Reviewers are asked to consider:

  • Originality, innovation, and scholarly significance;
  • Research design and methodological soundness;
  • Appropriateness of architectural, urban, spatial, or technical analyses;
  • Reliability and interpretation of research data;
  • Validity of findings and conclusions;
  • Engagement with relevant scientific literature;
  • Quality and clarity of drawings, maps, figures, and technical documentation;
  • Clarity, structure, and scholarly presentation;
  • Ethical considerations where applicable.

2.5 Editorial Decisions

Following evaluation, the editorial decision may be acceptance, revision, rejection, or a request for further assessment.

Final publication decisions are made by the responsible editor based on scholarly assessments and the journal's editorial standards.

2.6 Manuscript Revisions

Authors invited to revise their manuscripts should address reviewer and editor comments carefully and provide a structured response explaining the changes made.

Revised manuscripts may be returned for additional peer review when necessary.

3. Publication Ethics

AURAS expects authors, editors, and reviewers to follow established principles of ethical scholarly communication.

Plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, inappropriate authorship attribution, duplicate publication, manipulation of research data, and deliberate misrepresentation of findings are unacceptable.

In architectural and urban research, the unauthorized reproduction of architectural drawings, design concepts, maps, photographs, plans, technical documents, and other protected materials is also considered a serious ethical concern.

Suspected ethical violations are subject to editorial examination, taking into account available evidence, the nature of the allegation, and the need for a fair assessment.

4. Authorship and Contributorship

Authorship must reflect meaningful scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript.

All listed authors should approve the submitted manuscript, accept responsibility for their contributions, and disclose relevant conflicts of interest.

Contributions involving architectural design, field investigations, spatial analysis, technical modeling, experimental studies, data interpretation, or manuscript preparation should be appropriately recognized.

Individuals whose contributions do not justify authorship may be acknowledged.

5. Conflicts of Interest

Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose financial, professional, institutional, commercial, or personal relationships that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, their scholarly judgment.

Potential conflicts may arise from architectural consultancy, construction projects, commercial design activities, urban development investments, research sponsorships, or professional collaborations.

Editors must avoid handling manuscripts where their impartiality may be compromised.

6. Research Ethics and Informed Consent

Research involving human participants, residents, communities, interviews, surveys, personal information, or other ethically sensitive materials must comply with applicable legal and institutional requirements.

Authors are responsible for obtaining ethics committee approval and informed consent where required and for describing relevant ethical safeguards in their manuscripts.

Architectural and urban studies involving site investigations, heritage structures, private properties, or restricted locations must comply with applicable permissions and regulations.

Research involving environmental measurements, building performance assessments, or experimental construction materials must follow relevant scientific and safety standards.

7. Originality and Plagiarism

Manuscripts submitted to AURAS must represent original scholarly work and appropriately acknowledge previously published research.

The editorial team may examine manuscripts for textual overlap, unattributed material, duplicated figures, unauthorized use of architectural designs, and other concerns relating to originality.

Previously published architectural drawings, photographs, maps, technical illustrations, and design materials must be properly cited and accompanied by reuse permission where required.

A numerical similarity threshold will be announced separately if formally adopted by the journal.

8. Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Tools

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and scholarly validity of their submitted manuscripts.

Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors or co-authors because they cannot assume responsibility for scholarly publications.

Authors must disclose substantive use of generative artificial intelligence tools in manuscript preparation, research design, data analysis, image generation, architectural visualization, or other research activities, including the tool's name and purpose.

The use of AI-assisted architectural modeling, generative design systems, automated spatial analysis, or AI-generated visual materials must be transparently described when relevant to the research.

AI-generated images, architectural renderings, simulations, and technical representations must not be presented as authentic field observations, measured results, or completed physical structures unless accurately identified and supported by evidence.

Authors must verify AI-assisted content and ensure compliance with research ethics, copyright, confidentiality, and academic integrity requirements.

Editors and reviewers must protect the confidentiality of unpublished manuscripts when using digital or AI-assisted tools.

9. Corrections and Retractions

Concerns identified after publication may require editorial investigation and appropriate action to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record.

Depending on the circumstances, editorial actions may include corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions.

Decisions should consider available evidence, the seriousness of the concern, and fairness to the parties involved.

10. Complaints and Appeals

Authors and other stakeholders may raise concerns regarding editorial decisions, peer review procedures, or publication ethics.

Complaints and appeals should be supported by relevant information and will be considered according to principles of impartiality, confidentiality, and procedural fairness.

11. Data Availability and Transparency

Authors are encouraged to describe research methods, data sources, architectural measurements, spatial datasets, experimental procedures, and analytical techniques clearly enough to support scholarly evaluation.

Where appropriate and legally permissible, authors are encouraged to support research transparency and reproducibility by providing access to relevant datasets, technical documentation, simulation parameters, and supplementary materials.

Data involving private properties, protected heritage sites, personal information, or security-sensitive infrastructure must be handled in accordance with applicable confidentiality and legal requirements.

Any mandatory data-sharing requirements will be specified in a separately approved policy.

12. Open Access, Copyright and Licensing

Architecture, Urban Research and Analytical Studies (AURAS) is an open-access scholarly journal.

All published articles are made freely accessible to readers without subscription requirements.

Authors retain copyright to their published works.

Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license.

This license permits users to share and adapt published material for non-commercial purposes, provided that appropriate attribution is given to the original authors and publication source, a link to the license is supplied, and any modifications are indicated.

Commercial reuse requires separate permission from the copyright holder.

Authors must ensure that third-party architectural drawings, photographs, maps, plans, and other copyrighted materials included in their articles are used with appropriate permissions.

License: CC BY-NC 4.0 International

13. Publication Fees

Architecture, Urban Research and Analytical Studies (AURAS) operates under a fully free-of-charge publication model.

The journal does not charge authors any fees at any stage of manuscript submission, peer review, editorial evaluation, or publication.

  • Submission Fees: No manuscript submission fees are charged.
  • Article Processing Charges (APCs): No article processing charges are required.
  • Peer-Review Fees: No fees are charged for editorial evaluation or peer review.
  • Publication Fees: No fees are charged for accepted articles.
  • Additional Charges: No fees are imposed for manuscript revisions, article formatting, page length, architectural drawings, maps, or color figures.

All accepted articles are published as open-access content without financial obligations for authors.

AURAS is committed to providing an equitable, accessible, and inclusive scholarly publishing platform, ensuring that financial considerations do not constitute a barrier to the dissemination of high-quality architectural and urban research.

The journal's editorial and publication decisions are based exclusively on academic merit, originality, methodological quality, and compliance with ethical standards, regardless of authors' financial circumstances.

14. Archiving and Digital Preservation

Information about the journal's long-term digital preservation, repository arrangements, and archiving infrastructure will be provided when the relevant procedures have been established.

Publisher

Turkish Science and Technology Publishing (TURSTEP)